Former linebacker Chris Borland, who retired after one NFL season because of concerns about repetitive brain trauma, testified this afternoon at a hearing before the U.S. House Committee on Natural Resources’ Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations. He was one of four witnesses to tell the subcommittee about ways corporations use disinformation to mislead the public on matters including climate change and public health. Borland was there to discuss how the football establishment manipulates the science of brain injuries. What follows is the prepared text of the statement he read to the subcommittee. To the members of this committee, thank you for the privilege to testify today to discuss the nature of industry’s manipulation of science and policy as it pertains to brain injury in football. My name is Chris Borland. I was an All-American linebacker at the University of Wisconsin. In 2014, my first year in the National Football League, I led the San Francisco 49ers in tackles. I decided to walk away from the game of football after my rookie season in the NFL. While an active player in the NFL, I spent six months studying the available research on the ramifications of repetitive brain trauma. In relating what I found in the research to my own past experience with brain injury and to the demands of my job, I felt it was in the best interest of my personal health to stop playing football immediately. Per a 2014 NFL actuary, 28 percent of the league’s players will suffer from cognitive impairment. I had a history of brain injury and played an especially dangerous position as a middle linebacker. Personal experience is important in deciphering such data. Since leaving football in 2015, I have advocated for players and families that live with the consequences of brain injury. I’ve gained a keen insight into the failings of industry-funded research. Today, we continue to see industry-funded science misrepresenting the reality of what football players (as well as athletes in other violent games) experience in their sport. While much of the focus with brain injury research in football has been on the NFL, I would like to highlight how NCAA research into concussion is inherently flawed and why the NCAA fails to portray an accurate risk of brain damage for athletes competing under their organization. In 2014, the Department of Defense and NCAA collaborated to create what they call “The Grand Alliance,” a $30 million initiative to study concussion. Under the Grand Alliance, a program was launched dubbed the CARE Consortium. CARE is an acronym for concussion assessment, research, and education. In the words of the NCAA and Department of Defense, the Care Consortium “serves as the scientific and operational framework for the Concussion Research Initiative of the Grand Alliance.” To date, $64 million has been poured into The Care Consortium. There have been 40,000 athletes studied, and the NCAA and Department of Defense report to have captured 3,300 concussions. Due to disincentivization in reporting concussions that I understand well as a former Big Ten linebacker, I believe the figure of 3,300 concussions flawed to the point of being unusable. My intimate relationship with this research further bolsters my personal experience. The University of Wisconsin is a member institution in the Care Consortium. I have played with many men that were participants in the study. I know that most of these men appear in the research as having never sustained a concussion. That is, they have never reported sustaining a concussion. In my experience in football (which is not unique to that of my friends and teammates) symptoms of concussion, whether it be dizziness, tinnitus, imbalance, or others, were weekly occurrences during the season. The NCAA and Department of Defense routinely fail to acknowledge when sharing Care Consortium data, that an estimated 1/8 to 1/20 concussions is actually reported. A second glaring omission is that concussion is not believed by neuropathologists to be solely instrumental in brain diseases like Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy. Focusing only on concussion ignores the repetitive subconcussive hits to the head that football players experience, and that are believed to contribute to neurodegeneration. To be clear, I feel The Care Consortium does tremendous work researching concussion and developing protocols for those that have been diagnosed. My concern is that most of us athletes fall through the cracks. The Care Consortium data fails to take into account that the vast majority of concussions go undiagnosed. The Care Consortium focus on concussion does not capture what may be at the heart of the problem with brain injury in football, repetitive subconcussive hits. A true scientific and operational framework for concussion would include explicit acknowledgment that players so rarely report the injury. A genuine inquiry into brain damage from football must include mention of subconcussive hits. With The Care Consortium, the NCAA and Department of Defense have done a good job studying reported concussions. The Care Consortium has done a better job at distracting athletes and the public by excluding vital information and appropriate context. I deeply appreciate the opportunity to share my experience in football, with research, and as an advocate for former players. I’ll eagerly and happily answer any and all questions. Thank you!
Related Posts
Atletico Madrid s president said Monday he has received no offers for Argentine star Sergio Kun Aguero, a reported target of Chelsea, or Uruguayan striker Diego Forlan.
No club or representative has come to us, said Enrique Cerezo. We have no offers for our players.
We don t want to sell, the idea is to make a great team, he said.
British media reports last week said Chelsea had launched a 45-million-pound (53-million-euro) bid to sign the 21-year-old Aguero, who scored 17 goals last season to help Atletico claim a place in the Champions League.
Cerezo said he had not heard from Real Madrid s new president Florentino Perez, despite Spanish press reports the club was interested in Forlan, the top scorer in the Spanish league last season.
Atletic…
Coventry boss Mark Robins described Sheffield Wednesday fans who booed Kasey Palmer during his side’s FA Cup tie at Hillsborough as “idiots” and “absolute clowns”.
Djeidi Gassama’s late equaliser salvaged Wednesday a fourth-round replay after Danish midfielder Victor Torp had marked his Coventry debut with a stunning first-half opener.
Gassama denied the Sky Blues a second win at Hillsborough inside a week after their 2-1 Championship success on Saturday, which was marred by allegations of racist abuse towards their striker Palmer during the match.
We re all with you, Kasey.
— Coventry City (@Coventry_City)
Both clubs condemned the alleged abuse earlier this week and a man was arrested on Thursday, but Palmer was booed on several o…
A love of St Petersburg and a desire to bring success to Zenit was behind Hulk s decision to extend his contract until 2019.
Hulk says his happiness in St Petersburg and determination to drive Zenit to trophies were the reasons behind him signing a new deal with the club.
The Brazil forward, who put pen to paper on an extended contract until 2019 on Monday, is yet to win any silverware since moving to Russia from Porto in a big-money move in September 2012.
However, with Zenit sitting seven points clear at the top of the Premier League ahead of the division s resumption in March, Hulk looks set to lift his maiden Russian trophy this year.
And the 28-year-old is eyeing much more success in the coming years.
I was really happy, Hulk told Zenit…
West Ham manager Slaven Bilic is wary of Jermain Defoe s absurd finishing ahead of his team s hosting of Sunderland.
Defoe, 34, already has four Premier League goals this season, continuing where he left off in a fine last campaign.
David Moyes men are battling and bottom of the table, and Defoe has four of their six league goals.
Bilic was full of praise for Defoe, who has returned to England in fine form after his spell with Toronto in MLS in 2014.
He has come back from America maybe better than before, which is amazing, he said.
I spoke with Niko Kranjcar, my midfield player for Croatia, who played with Jermain at Portsmouth and Spurs.
As a number 10 he played with some good strikers and he told me that by far the best movement of a …
Best Odds: 19/20
Bookmaker:
With all eyes from across Europe falling on the Spanish capital this weekend, Atletico Madrid and Los Blancos will meet at the Metropolitano Stadium on Sunday night.
Atletico Madrid
Starting with the hosts, coming off the back of a nightmare display while on Champions League duties earlier in the week, Atletico Madrid will be seeking an immediate response here. However, eventually getting hit with a late 2-0 loss away at German outfit Bayer Leverkusen, Los Colchoneros have shown some inconsistencies since opening the 2022/23 campaign. While they might have been last seen on La Liga action storming their way to a routine 4-1 romp against Celta Vigo on home soil, Diego Simeone s men open this weekend s fixtures sat down in seventh plac…
With all eyes from across the Premier League falling on St. James’ Park, Arsenal claimed what was a crucial 2-0 victory away at Newcastle on Sunday afternoon.
Traveling to the north east knowing that a single point was not enough, it was the red-hot Martin Odegaard who opened the scoring with a sublime effort after just 14 minutes.
With the Gunners’ skipper now notching five Premier League goals in as many appearances, Mikel Arteta’s young squad certainly showed their mental resolve here.
Eventually claiming what could turn out to be a season-defining victory away from the Emirates as Fabian Schar unfortunately turned into his own net on the 71st minute, Newcastle will certainly feel that they done enough to leave St. James’ Park with something to show f…
Holders Atletico Madrid will look to gain a healthy advantage in their Copa del Rey last-16 first leg with Segunda B outfit Sant Andreu.
Diego Simone s charges who defeated city rivals Real Madrid 2-1 after extra time in last season s final head into the match as overwhelming favourites following a superb start to their Liga campaign.
Atletico have lost just once all season, and sit joint top with reigning champions Barcelona after 15 games.
Their latest success came in a 2-0 triumph at Elche last Saturday, a result that followed a 7-0 demolition of Getafe at Vicente Calderon.
If, as expected, Atletico come through the encounter against their third-tier opponents, a quarter-final tie with Gimnastic or Valencia will await.
La Liga leaders Barcelona have won…
that Bayern Munich and Arsenal are among the clubs keeping close tabs on Hoffenheim winger Kevin Volland.
The 21-year-old joined the Bundesliga side in the summer of 2011 from 1860 Munchen and has since impressed at the biggest stage.
After netting 6 league goals in his first season at the club, Volland has already registered 7 goals this term, and has in turn impressed the visiting scouts.
As a result, Bayern Munich, Arsenal, Manchester United, Chelsea and Liverpool are all believed to be keen, although they have yet to make their interest concrete.
Volland has a contract until June 2017 and is valued at £12 million, with the asking price unlikely to put off any of his suitors.
Hoffenheim did well to hold mighty Borussia Dortmund to a 2-2 draw…
EA Sports has revealed the 10 highest-rated players on FIFA 20 ahead of the game s release later this month, with Lionel Messi back on top after Cristiano Ronaldo ranked first last year.
Messi enjoyed another stellar campaign for Barcelona in 2018-19, scoring 36 goals in 34 LaLiga matches, inspiring the club s title defence and run to the Champions League semi-finals.
Ronaldo s first season at Juventus – who will be known as Piemonte Calcio on FIFA 20 – went as smoothly as might have been expected, with the forward finishing as the club s top-scorer as they claimed an eighth successive Scudetto, though that was not enough to retain his crown as FIFA s highest-rated player.
Neither Ronaldo nor Messi were able to win the Champions League, however, with that hon…
Manchester City want to tie Raheem Sterling down to a new long-term contract but manager Pep Guardiola concedes he is unsure over whether the England international will agree terms.
Gabriel Jesus became the latest of City s key players to commit his future to the Premier League champions on Friday, penning a renewed deal through until June 2023.
During their triumphant campaign last season, Kevin De Bruyne, David Silva, Fernandinho, Nicolas Otamendi and Ederson all signed fresh terms.
Sterling is yet to join that quintet despite scoring 23 goals in all competitions in 2017-18 for City, although talks have taken place with the 23-year-old s representatives as he enters the penultimate season of his current contract.
The 23-year-old will not feature against…